Different trade patterns and inspection rates along with the use of umbrella terms results in variable patterns of substitution in shark, hake, and flatfish sold in Minas Gerais, Brazil

Jonathan Ready1, Luara Falcão1, Cristiane Araujo2, Bruno Pardinho2, Núbia Guimarães2, Lorena Freitas2, João Bráullio L. Sales1, Izabela S. Mendes2,3 and Daniel Cardoso Carvalho2.4

PDF: Download Here | Supplementary: Sup | Cite this article

Associate Editor: Alexandre W. Hilsdord

Section Editor: Fernando Pelicice

Editor-in-chief: José Birindelli

Abstract​


EN
PT

A substituição e rotulagem incorreta de produtos pesqueiros constituem problemas globais. Eles são resultado de fatores econômicos, aliados à déficits de legislação e fiscalização, mas o papel do comércio diferenciado entre produtos não tem sido amplamente abordado. Investigamos as taxas de rotulagem incorreta e substituição em três produtos pesqueiros em Minas Gerais, no Brasil (tubarão, merluza e peixe-chato), onde padrões de comercialização variam. Substituições em produtos comercializados internacionalmente (tubarão e merluza) foram encontradas apenas em produtos não certificados de peixarias, indicando vendas oportunistas de produtos perecíveis disponíveis. Uma taxa maior de rotulagem incorreta foi observada em peixes-chatos comercializados nacionalmente, inclusive em produtos certificados, mas foi considerado não intencional. Diferenças internacionais na demanda cultural por produtos (por exemplo, barbatanas versus carne de tubarões), combinada com taxas variáveis ​​de inspeção de alimentos em diferentes pontos de venda, podem contribuir para aumentar o risco de substituições. Produtos congelados de fornecedores certificados no Brasil são geralmente inspecionados por agentes governamentais oficiais em campanhas focando em supermercados. Esses sistemas de alta inspeção apresentam uma baixa probabilidade de substituição de produtos, mas também podem apresentar alguns erros não intencionais de rotulagem. Em contraste, produtos frescos de peixarias não são alvos dessas inspeções. Esses sistemas de baixa inspeção estão mais propensos a apresentar um maior risco de substituição intencional, que pode ser oportunista, dependendo das circunstâncias específicas.

Palavras-chave: Actinopterígeos, Elasmobrânquios, Fraude alimentar, Oportunismo, Rotas comerciais.

Introduction​


The collapse of many commercially important fish stocks has led to an intense focus on seafood identification to support consumer-driven sustainable consumption (Logan et al., 2008; Mariani et al., 2015; Brechón et al., 2016; Carvalho et al., 2011, 2017a,b; Guardone et al., 2017; Delpiani et al., 2020). In Brazil, the official inspection of seafood products made by the Agriculture Ministry (Ministério da Agricultura, Agropecuária e Abastecimento – MAPA) has performed both traditional and molecular identification on seafood products sold in 14 Brazilian states (Carvalho et al., 2017a). Brazilian national legislation uses a hybrid system of umbrella terms, common names and taxonomic identification that aims to provide inspection cover for the most lucrative commercial species that are theoretically at most risk from overfishing (Brasil, 2004, 2015, 2020). Because of logistic challenges associated with the geographic scale of the country and the large numbers of artisanal fishermen and local markets, inspection does not cover sales from most local markets and street vendors. This facilitates fraud and mislabeling practices in non-industrial and informal trade routes (Palmeira et al., 2013; Ferrette et al., 2019; Rodrigues-Filho et al., 2020). Additionally, variation in the use of common names further complicates the inspection of fisheries products in different regions (Rodrigues-Filho et al.,2009; Brito et al., 2015).

The global consumption of fisheries products has increased above human population growth and now represents more than 9% of total agricultural exports (FAO, 2018). Much of this trade results from supply and demand issues associated with the differential trading powers, as well as cultural demands for certain products in different countries (Can et al., 2015). A combination of the scarcity of resources, the potential for higher profits, and weak legislation also encourage mislabeling (Jacquet, Pauly, 2008), but in some cases species substitution is not always intentional. For example, unintentional substitution may occur due to the difficulty of distinguishing species because of their morphological similarity (Schröder, 2007; Lo, Shaw, 2018; Donlan, Luque, 2019) or because of the use of the same or similar common names across various species (Brito et al., 2015). The latter is more likely to occur in processed products which no longer retain clear characteristics for morphological identification (Di Pinto et al., 2015). However, even in high value products such as tuna, common names can also be used to mislabel products (Vandamme et al., 2016).

Fisheries catch data and commercial trade data are essential to improve management actions/laws and predict economic drivers that can influence the supply and demand for fisheries products (Fox et al., 2018; Cawthorn et al., 2018; Ehmke et al., 2019). Some fish species are targeted for economic interests that result from demands for muscle consistency, flavor, or social status/cultural issues (Can et al., 2015). For example, the demand for shark fins, used to make soup in some Asian cultures, drives many shark fisheries across the world, including significant exports from Brazilian waters (Dent, Clarke, 2015; Ferrette et al., 2019). Brazil has been identified both as the main exporter of shark in the world (Dent, Clark, 2015) and, curiously, as the greatest importer of shark meat (Barreto et al., 2017; Dulvy et al., 2017). The high international demand combined with low inspection rates favor mislabeling that threatens protected species (Bornatowski et al., 2013). Endangered species including a variety of elasmobranchs and teleosts have been identified in shark products in many countries (Carvalho et al., 2015; Almerón-Souza et al., 2018; Calegari et al., 2019; Ferrito et al., 2019; Hobbs et al., 2019; Pazartzi et al., 2019; Delpiani et al., 2020; Bernardo et al., 2020; Marchetti et al., 2020).

In Brazil, shark fishing represents an important resource, with fins sold overseas and meat sold locally. Although shark meat is considered low quality, it is a cheap protein source for many people (Gemaque et al., 2017; Feitosa et al., 2018). On the other hand, products such as hake and flatfish are sold as high value products in Brazil, at least in part due to cultural inheritance of diets from Portugal (Maciel et al., 2016). Only one species of hake (Merluccius hubbsi) is recorded from the Brazilian coast but is not abundant and much of the demand for hake must therefore be supplied by imports (Vaz-dos-Santos, Schwingel, 2015). In comparison flatfish are represented by many species, but only two genera of the family Paralichthyidae (Syacium spp. and Paralichthys spp.) can be traded as “linguado” (Brasil, 2015, 2020). Trade in some fish products such as flatfish may also be reduced because of changes in the quality of tissues during freezing for long distance transport (Massa et al., 2005). Furthermore, automated filleting of these morphologically distinct species requires different technologies (Hjorth, 1996) that may not be worth the investment when considering the ratio of sales prices in local and distant markets.

Shark, hake and flatfishes are important fisheries products and easily found in fish markets, supermarkets and online suppliers in Brazil. Therefore, we aimed to assess the true diversity of species represented in products sold under the common names “cação” (shark), “merluza” (hake) and “linguado” (flatfish) from these different commercial sources in southeastern Brazil through molecular identification using the DNA barcoding fragment of the mitochondrial Cytochrome Oxidase Subunit I (CoxI) gene (Hebert et al., 2003). Based on this data we have evaluated: (1) whether common names are masking errors in labeling; and (2) whether rates of mislabeling vary based on the different points of sale considering the different inspection probabilities and variation in how supply and demand affect the distinct sales routes.

Material and methods


Sample collection. A total of 191 samples from products sold as “cação”(shark, N = 66), “merluza”(hake, N = 49) and “linguado” (flatfish, N = 76) were purchased in supermarkets, fishmongers/street vendors and e-commerce at Minas Gerais, southeastern Brazil, between 2014 and 2019 (Tab. S1). Small tissue pieces were collected and preserved in 100% ethanol. Information about each sample was recorded for subsequent analysis: total price (R$), weight (kg), brand name, name of vendor (store name or fishmonger), format of product (fillet, slices, whole, etc.), and whether or not there was a Federal Inspection Service stamp (SIF – required and present on branded products from large suppliers and generally sold in supermarkets and e-commerce).

DNA extraction and COI gene fragment amplification and sequencing. DNA was extracted using a modified salting-out protocol (Aljanabi, Martinez, 1997). Partial COI gene sequences of approximately 650 base pairs (bp) were obtained by PCR (Polymerase Chain Reaction) using the primers FishF1 and FishR1 (Ward et al., 2005). PCR reactions consisted of 1.0 µl of 5x GoTaq DNA polymerase reaction buffer (Promega, Madison USA), 0.2 µl of mixed dNTP (40 mM, Promega, Madison USA), 0.3 µl of MgCl2 (Promega, Madison USA), 0.2 µl of each primer (10 µM, Integrated DNA Technologies – IDT), 0.1 µl of Go Taq polymerase (Promega, Madison USA), 7.0 µl of ultrapure water and 1.0 µl of genomic DNA. PCR conditions comprised an initial step of 2 min at 95 oC followed by 35 cycles of 30 s at 95 oC, 30 s at 54 oC and 60 s at 72 oC, and one final step of 10 min at 72 oC. PCR products were visualized using a 1% agarose gel to check amplification. DNA sequencing was then conducted in both directions using primers FishF1 or FishR1 and BigDye Kit v. 3.1 (Life Technologies). Sequences were obtained using an automated DNA sequencer (ABI3130, Life technologies).

Molecular data analysis. DNA sequences were edited using SeqScape® v. 2.7 (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) and MEGA X (Kumar et al., 2018). The consensus sequences were compared to existing data on BOLD (http://www.boldsystems.org/) and GenBank (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genbank) as a method of sample identification using the BOLD Identification tool and Blastn available on National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI). Top species matches obtained from searches were recorded using a 99% threshold. Scientific names were associated with the corresponding market names following the official governmental regulatory list of species in Brazil for the relevant time period (Brasil, 2015, 2020). Other vernacular names derived from FishBase (Froese, Pauly, 2020) were used when scientific names of species were not found in the official governmental list. As DNA sequences were not recovered from voucher samples and were only used to assign identity, they were not deposited in GenBank or BOLD.

Import/Export data. Brazilian export and import data (quantity and value) for all three taxonomic groups (including shark fins) were obtained from Comex Stat of the Ministério da Indústria, Comércio Exterior e Serviços (MDIC). We used the Comex categorization “Chapter 03” under the harmonized 2-digit system (SH2) code to obtain all the available data for “Fish and crustaceans, mollusks and other aquatic invertebrates” for the years 2008–2019. This search generated an Excel file for each year with hundreds of types of fish products, including live animals. The information on traded products (volumes and values) is divided by countries of origin and destination and includes an 8-digit Mercosur Common Nomenclature (NCM) commodity code. From this raw data, the commodity code, annual value, quantity and destination or origin for shark, hake, and flatfish products were filtered including the full range of common names (as described above but also including the name ‘peixes chatos’ for flatfishes) applied to these products. The filtered data was exported for each of the three taxonomic target groups and summary statistics calculated to compare export and import values and quantities. For flatfish products we noted but eventually excluded data for the commodities named as giant flatfishes (‘linguados gigantes’ – the halibuts) from statistical summaries as these represent very distinct products with distinct patterns of commerce to the smaller flatfishes that were the focus of the molecular identification analyses.

Shark meat availability from fin/dressed weight ratios in export and fisheries statistics. As sharks are exported as meat and fins, we estimated maximum and minimum mass of remaining shark meat in the national market based on fin weight to dressed weight ratios. Fin weight (wet) is considered to represent between 14.72% (Mejuto, García-Cortés, 2004), or between 15.97% (with skin) and 19.2% (without skin) dressed body weight (Espino et al., 2010). The ratio between dry fin weight and wet fin weight in sharks varies between 39.5% ±0.7 and 54% depending on species (see tab. 4 in Rose et al., 2003). We therefore derived a minimum dry fin weight to dressed weight ratio of 5.81% (14.72 x 0.395). The conversion factor for estimating the maximum weight of shark meat remaining for a given weight of exported fins is calculated based on dry fin weight and was therefore 17.21 (100/5.81). Similarly, the conversion factor for estimating the minimum weight of shark meat remaining for a given value of exported fins is calculated based on the maximal wet fin weight to dressed weight ratio and was therefore 5.21 (100/19.2). The weight of shark meat exports was then deducted from these estimates to provide the theoretical minimum and maximum values for shark meat that remains in the Brazilian market for consumption each year based on exported fins in that year. In order to compare the weight of meat from imports and exports with biomass obtained from fisheries, fisheries catch statistics were obtained from national reports covering all years with available data (Annual fisheries reports – Brasil, 2010, 2012).

Results​


Overall substitution rates were low (17/191 or 8.9%), but molecular identification detected clear cases of fraud by substitution in non-SIF certified products sold by fishmongers (Tab. 1). These included 41.6% (5/12) of hake samples and 2.56% (1/39) of shark samples (Tab. 1), and both were substituted by freshwater catfishes. Mislabeling was otherwise only found in flatfish samples (from all sources), but was assigned to be a result of misidentification error rather than intentional substitution because of the morphological similarity of the named species (other flatfishes).

TABLE 1 | Summary of the samples of shark, hake and flatfish obtained from the different points of sale in southeastern Brazil for molecular identification with the number of mislabeled samples indicated in parentheses.

Label

Total sample number

Supermarket samples (SIF stamp)

Fish market samples (no SIF stamp)

Online supplier samples (no SIF stamp)

Number of species identified

“Cação” (shark)

66 (1)

27

39 (1)

0

4

“Merluza” (hake)

49 (5)

37

12 (5)

0

4

“Linguado” (flatfish)

76 (11)

46 (6)

8 (3)

22 (2)

3

Sum

191 (17)

110 (6)

59 (9)

22 (2)

11


Of the 66 shark samples analyzed, 63 were identified as Prionace glauca (blue shark or tubarão-azul in Portuguese and now officially classified on ZooBank
(urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:C8D7ACD8-600C-4918-A406-4B899CA849B2), two as Carcharhinus glaucus, Rodrigues-Filho et al.,2023), one identified as Carcharhinus leucas (bull shark or tubarão-touro in Portuguese), one as Carcharhinus acronotus (blacknose shark or cação-lombo-preto in Portuguese) and one as Brachyplatystoma vaillantii (Laulao catfish or piramutaba in Portuguese) (Tab. S1). Almost all products were labeled only with the name “cação”, but six of the brands indicated the specific name Prionace glauca on their packaging, and all 16 of the samples from these brands were identified by DNA barcode to belong to this species. The price per kilo of the shark products analyzed ranged from R$ 11.27 to R$ 53.89 (Tab. S1), with higher cost for some supermarket products and for the one fish market sample that was a bull shark rather than a blue shark. The substituted sample CA_AM63 sold at R$ 17.00 per kilo as “cação”, compares reasonably in value to the actual product sold (piramutaba) which varied between R$ 10 and R$ 25 per kilo in 2014 (minimum and maximum prices from online searches of wholesaler data for the relevant sampling period, with lower prices in northern Brazil and higher prices in southern Brazil).

Of the 49 hake samples analyzed, 27 were identified as the Argentine hake, Merluccius hubbsi, 12 as the North Pacific hake Merluccius productus, five as the South Pacific hake Merluccius gayi and five as the freshwater catfish Hypophthalmus marginatus (Highwaterman catfish or mapará in Portuguese) (Tab. S1). Hake from different regions were found mixed in one supermarket pack (both Argentine and North Pacific hake in pack 5). All five mislabeled products were obtained from a fishmonger (no pack, label or SIF certification) and are equivalent to 41.6% (5/12) of fishmonger samples and just over 10% (5/49) of all hake samples. The price per kilo of the hake products analyzed ranged from R$ 8.90 to R$ 25.50, with the substituted products sold at R$ 14.90 per kilo (Tab. 2). Fish sold as “mapará” at the time cost between R$ 10 and R$ 20 per kilo (prices paid for samples at the same time but not used in this study).

TABLE 2 | Value in 1000s of US$, weight in tons, and main origin of Brazilian imports of shark, hake and flatfish products between 2008 and 2019.


Shark (Tubarão)

Hake (Merluza)

Flatfish (Linguado)

Year

1000s US$

Tons

Origin

1000s US$

Tons

Origin

1000s US$

Tons

Origin

2008

33,495.5

17,856.6

Portugal

698.7

459.3

Chile

282.9

114.7

Uruguay

2009

37,938.0

21,230.5

Chile

1,328.8

1,123.3

Singapore

480.2

206.6

Argentina

2010

40,594.0

18,605.3

Uruguay

3,055.9

2,170.5

Argentina

144.4

87.2

Uruguay

2011

44,151.4

19,373.9

Uruguay

3,735.5

2,086.3

Argentina

12.0

6.5

Uruguay

2012

36,818.5

21,315.4

Uruguay

186,128.5

76,449.9

China

1,913.1

702.6

China

2013

41,085.0

19,384.1

Taiwan

209,596.8

92,728.9

China

2,420.5

1,069.8

China

2014

45,254.0

17,412.6

Taiwan

177,037.4

69,919.4

China

2,610.7

1,136.0

China

2015

26,855.8

12,833.0

Taiwan

154,986.7

60,427.0

China

6,191.5

2,915.8

China

2016

24,836.3

15,939.9

Taiwan

107,804.7

45,530.4

China

2,372.0

1,267.8

China

2017

37,403.3

20,799.6

Taiwan

150,998.9

55,854.8

Argentina

1,082.6

354.3

China

2018

40,767.0

18,372.0

Taiwan

135,345.7

46,002.6

Argentina

301.3

67.2

China

2019

33,010.7

15,865.3

Taiwan

135,914.3

43,589.3

Argentina

1,173.8

306.1

China


Of the 76 flatfish samples analyzed, 34 were identified as the Patagonian flounder Paralichthys patagonicus, 31 as P. isosceles and 11 as Xystreurys rasile. All the packs were identified only with the umbrella term “linguado” (flatfish). Xystreurys rasile is not on the official list of species allowed to be sold as “linguado” in Brazil (Brasil, 2015, 2020). These Normative Instructions only allow species of the genera Paralichthys and Syacium to be sold under the label “linguado”. However, X. rasile is also a member of the pleuronectiform family Paralichthyidae and we have considered that this mislabeling represents both an inability to distinguish these taxa and a lack of awareness of the limitations of the umbrella term “linguado” in legislative terms rather than an example of intentional substitution. This mislabeling was also found across all sources of samples, though the mislabeling rate was highest in samples from fishmongers (3/8 or 37.5%, compared to 6/45 or 13.3% in supermarket sourced samples and 2/21 or 9.5% in e-commerce sourced samples). Multiple species were identified packed together in single packs. Packs 1, 15 and 16 from supermarkets contained mixes of P. isosceles and X. rasile, while packs 7 and 10 contained fillets of all three species (Tab. S1). Mislabeled products (or packs containing these) were generally sold within the same per kilo price range of the other samples sold as “linguado”.

Export and import data for shark, hake and flatfish products between 2008 and 2019 provides an overview of supply and demand (Tabs. 2–3). Most products are grouped under generalized fisheries products codes (e.g., “shark meat” or “flatfish”) that do not allow species level analyses. Generally, imports far exceed exports, but for specific products there is some variation. This is clear for sharks where there was a net excess export of shark fins and net excess import of shark meat (Tabs. 2–5). There is a clear shift in trading partners from countries speaking Spanish and Portuguese to Taiwan for shark imports (predominantly meat) from 2012 to 2013 but shark exports (predominantly fins) were always to the far east.

TABLE 3 | Value in 1000s of US$, weight in tons, and main destination of Brazilian exports of shark, hake and flatfish products between 2008 and 2019.


Shark (Tubarão)

Hake (Merluza)

Flatfish (Linguado)

Year

1000s US$

Tons

Destination

1000s US$

Tons

Destination

1000s US$

Tons

Destination

2008

2,825.5

112.5

Hong Kong

420.2

137.4

Belgium

174.4

73.7

United States

2009

2,338.1

85.4

Hong Kong

34.5

10.9

U.K.

38.0

16.6

United States

2010

1,431.4

51.0

Hong Kong

–

–

–

2.2

2.0

United States

2011

2,203.7

83.2

Hong Kong

0.5

0.1

Paraguay

17.2

26.3

China

2012

1,789.2

43.9

Hong Kong

1.3

0.2

Paraguay

955.7

436.0

Angola

2013

1,293.5

31.2

Hong Kong

12.4

1.3

Equat. Guinea

524.2

265.3

South Korea

2014

978.3

27.7

Hong Kong

7.1

1.5

Angola

859.8

448.5

South Korea

2015

812.6

27.5

Hong Kong

–

–

–

703.9

337.7

China

2016

810.7

34.5

Hong Kong

68.6

29.7

China

156.8

73.4

Vietnam

2017

1,063.4

44.1

Hong Kong

50.2

21.1

China

2,312.0

639.1

United States

2018

1,320.1

44.0

Hong Kong

1,211.6

415.6

China

532.4

267.0

China

2019

934.8

63.6

Hong Kong

979.7

265.8

Argentina

1,165.6

637.7

China


TABLE 4 | Value in US$, weight in Kg, and mean price US$ per Kg for shark products (meat and fins) exported from Brazil between 2008 and 2019.


Shark meat

Shark fins

Year

U$$

Kg

Mean price

U$$

Kg

Mean price

2008

–

–


2,825,451.00

112,505.00

25.11

2009

–

–


2,338,059.00

85,382.00

27.38

2010

–

–


1,431,446.00

50,957.00

28.09

2011

94,979.00

24,508.00

3.88

2,108,735.00

58,740.00

35.90

2012

12,678.00

4,580.00

2.77

1,776,538.00

39,355.00

45.14

2013

–

–


1,293,518.00

31,191.00

41.47

2014

–

–


978,308.00

27,741.00

35.27

2015

–

–


812,554.00

27,542.00

29.50

2016

18,114.00

10,426.00

1.74

792,584.00

24,105.00

32.88

2017

26,100.00

12,617.00

2.07

1,037,341.00

31,474.00

32.96

2018

26,023.00

11,333.00

2.30

1,294,042.00

43,706.00

29.61

2019

104,914.00

41,149.00

2.55

829,852.00

22,487.00

36.90

All years

282,808.00

104,613.00

2.70

17,518,428.00

555,185.00

31.55


TABLE 5 | Analysis of the permanence of shark meat in the Brazilian consumer market between 2008 and 2019 based on the registered commercial weights of exported fins and meat and using minimum and maximum conversion factors between the fin’s weight and the individual (see methods for details about conversion factors). *Mean and standard deviation calculated only for 2012–2019 used as they represent the most recent data with relatively stable values.

Year(s)

Fin exports (kg)

Minimum excess meat (kg) based on a conversion factor of 5.21

Maximum excess meat (kg) based on a conversion factor of 17.21

Meat exports (kg)

Minimum excess meat (kg) left to internal market

Maximum excess meat (kg) left to internal market

2008

112,505.00

586,151.05

1,936,211.05

0.00

586,151.05

1,936,211.05

2009

85,382.00

444,840.22

1,469,424.22

0.00

444,840.22

1,469,424.22

2010

50,957.00

265,485.97

876,969.97

0.00

265,485.97

876,969.97

2011

58,740.00

306,035.40

1,010,915.40

24,508.00

281,527.40

986,407.40

2012

39,355.00

205,039.55

677,299.55

4,580.00

200,459.55

672,719.55

2013

31,191.00

162,505.11

536,797.11

0.00

162,505.11

536,797.11

2014

27,741.00

144,530.61

477,422.61

0.00

144,530.61

477,422.61

2015

27,542.00

143,493.82

473,997.82

0.00

143,493.82

473,997.82

2016

24,105.00

125,587.05

414,847.05

10,426.00

115,161.05

404,421.05

2017

31,474.00

163,979.54

541,667.54

12,617.00

151,362.54

529,050.54

2018

43,706.00

227,708.26

752,180.26

11,333.00

216,375.26

740,847.26

2019

22,487.00

117,157.27

387,001.27

41,149.00

76,008.27

345,852.27

2012–2019* Mean

30,950.13

161,250.15

532,651.65

10,013.13

151,237.03

522,638.53

2012–2019* Standard deviation

7,310.27

38,086.53

125,809.82

13,671.88

44,494.95

130,941.70


Hake products were imported in large quantities but there is little export, and flatfish were neither imported nor exported in large quantities (<1,000 tonnes per year). In many cases flatfish and hake exports showed onward shipping of non-native fish species that must have come from previous imports e.g., although we excluded them from statistical analyses, we noted that data in 2011 indicted export of northern cold-water halibuts (Reinhardtius hippoglossoides, Hippoglossus hippoglossus, H. stenolepis) to Singapore.

By analyzing the discrepancy in mass of shark fins and body (meat) in export data from 2008 to 2019, we estimate a minimum excess of ~76 tonnes of shark meat in 2019 and that since 2012, when export volumes of shark fins stabilized, an average of between 151 and 522 tonnes of excess shark meat is available annually in the domestic market (Tab. 5). Unfortunately, data is not available between 2011 and 2022, but Brazilian fishing statistics indicate annual catches ranging from 9,147.5 tons for a “number of shark species” in 2000 to 11,750 tons for “sharks and blue sharks” in 2011 (Brazil, 2010, 2012).

Discussion​


This study targeted three main groups of fisheries products to investigate how substitution might be affected by inspection rates and market forces. The substitution rate encountered (8.9% overall and 0% in SIF certified products when discounting accidental mislabeling in flatfish) are lower than that found in most previous work (Carvalho et al., 2011; Staffen et al., 2017; Souza et al., 2021), but follows the trend found by Brazilian government monitoring of SIF certified products in recent years. The Ministério da Agricultura Agropecuária e Abastecimento (MAPA) started checking mislabeling of SIF certified products bought in 2014, when mislabeling was found in 23% of products (DIPOA, 2015). In 2016 this had reduced to approximately 16% (DIPOA, 2016) and 3% in 2017 (DIPOA, 2018) but then increased again in 2018 to 13% (DIPOA, 2019). Most of our samples were obtained in 2016 after inspection in the region had already become a newsworthy issue (Carvalho et al., 2015). This shows that inspection has an effect in reducing mislabeling in certified sources. However, inspection at local markets remains a problem because of the distributed nature of these markets and the dominance of uncertified fresh products for sale. These are the main locations where substitution has been identified, both in this study (41.6% in hake products and 37.5% in flatfish products) and in others in Brazil (Almerón-Souza et al., 2018; Carvalho et al., 2017a) and around the world (Cawthorn et al., 2012; Marchetti et al., 2020). Indeed, 62% of fishes marketed as grouper were found to represent sharks with most of this substitution occurring in informal markets and fishmongers compared to much lower rates in supermarkets and restaurants in São Paulo State (Estrella et al., 2016). These informal markets and fishmongers are also recorded as more likely to sell products from protected species (Palmeira et al., 2013; Bernardo et al., 2020).

Intentional substitution can be predicted to be governed by opportunism in the context of the sale environment (Estrella et al., 2016) and not just because of price differences (Donlan, Luque, 2019). The sale environment includes both risk factors for those attempting substitution and economic factors that control the market. Both the legislation (use of umbrella terms vs. species specific labelling) and the frequency and coverage of inspection determine the risk of performing substitution in the sale environment. Economically, supply, demand and transportability regulate the species available at given prices, with temporal management of product stock more manageable for frozen processed products than for fresh products. This context dependent analysis of substitution likelihood explains the results of our analyses.

The substitution of shark and hake by the freshwater catfishes (B. vaillantii and H. marginatus, respectively) appears to be a result of intentional but opportunistic substitution. We conclude this because: 1) before being prepared for sale the species are morphologically very distinct from each other (so fishmongers should know very well which one is which); and, 2) the catfish species have similar or higher prices to shark or hake so no, or limited, direct profit is made on the item. Substitution of products with similarly priced or more expensive products may be a common opportunistic practice for fishmongers. Their products are mainly perishable (fresh fish) that, unlike frozen fillets, must be sold as soon as possible to minimize economic losses. In comparison SIF certified products are normally frozen and can be sold over a longer time so that the percentage of loss in unsold goods is minimized by store management practices that balance supply and demand. This also may explain why catfish have been substituted rather than marine fishes with similar quality meat and/or taste. To a consumer, the size, shape and color of the final processed products may be more similar to their expectations for the requested product than any of the available marine species in the fishmonger’s stock.

Although previous studies have already pointed out substitution in flatfish species in Brazil (Carvalho et al., 2015, 2017a; Staffen et al., 2017), the substitutions indicated in the present study can be interpreted as unintentional. The adoption of broad terms for legislative purposes must consider the common use of the term itself and the likelihood of its misapplication. Many flatfish from various families of the Order Pleuronectiformes are morphologically very similar to each other and are commonly identified under the term “linguado” in the southeastern and southern regions of Brazil, with different vernacular names (often “solha”) more often used in the northeastern and northern regions. The use of the term should therefore be restricted to only two genera of a given family as more recently applied in Normative Instruction No 53 (Brasil, 2020) so that there can be a consistent application of names by fishermen, as well as fish processing and distribution centers, reducing the chance of mislabeling of some products.

Brazilian legislation does not require the use of species names on packaging. Umbrella terms such as “cação”, “merluza” and “linguado” (shark, hake and flatfish, respectively) are used (Brasil, 2020), and multiple species were found to be commercialized under each of these three umbrella terms. However, some seafood brands named the shark species on their packaging and molecular analysis of these samples confirmed the labels to be correct. A lack of proper identification on packages prevents consumers from making choices important for sustainability and human health (Jacquet, Pauly, 2008; Vitale et al., 2020), especially for top predators such as sharks that can accumulate heavy metals and other toxic substances (Lopes et al., 2019; Pancaldi et al., 2019). Mercury has been found above allowed concentrations in blue shark meat from the South Atlantic (Carvalho et al., 2014) and blue sharks were the predominant species identified in our shark samples, indicating health risks for consumers of these products.

International trade is currently one of the main drivers that determine the value of products (Garcia, Rosenberg, 2010; Purcell et al., 2017) and is an important consideration in the development of sustainable fisheries (Potts, Haward, 2007; Stephenson et al., 2019). Price in turn is a driver of the likelihood of substitution (EFSA, 2012; USP, 2016:1586–1621). There are clear differences in the trading of the three taxonomic groups studied here with variation in the balance of imports and exports and distinct differences for trade of the different shark products (fins vs. meat). Cultural demands are well known as the cause of some of these differences (Can et al., 2015; Maciel et al., 2016) and the processing capacity and transportability of products may also impact their trade (Hjorth, 1996; Massa et al., 2005). But how these factors act as drivers for substitution will also vary based on the fisheries products harvested by any given country and the role of that country within the trading network. Here we show for sharks that despite considerable volumes of excess meat generated by fisheries (Tab. 5) after the export of fins to the orient (Tabs. 3–4) there is still a huge demand for cheap protein and that shark meat is still imported in large amounts (Tab. 2). Hake is also imported to Brazil in large volumes for consumption (Tab. 2). For both hake and shark products the retail chain of certified products can easily adapt to sell only legal products, with substitutions only occurring at points of sale where inspection is less risky. In comparison, international trade of flatfish is minimal (Tabs. 2–3) and local supply and demand factors are dominant in determining sales prices. When problems associated with the use of umbrella terms and the morphological similarity of flatfish are also considered, a higher likelihood of substitution and mislabeling in these products is expected.

Elasmobranchs represent less than 1% of all marine fisheries worldwide (FAO, 2014, 2016), but these species have biological characteristics including slow growth, late sexual maturation and limited reproductive output, that make them particularly prone to overfishing (Bornatowski et al., 2014) and many species have experienced severe population declines in the last 20 years (Stevens et al., 2000; FAO, 2020; Gebremedhin et al., 2021). Although no substitutions for protected species were detected in certified shark products sold in supermarkets, some shark species identified here are classified as Endangered (EN) (C. acronotus), Vulnerable (VU) (C. leucas), and Near-Threatened (NT) (C. glaucus) (Rigby et al., 2019, 2021; Carlson et al., 2021). The role of informal markets in the sale of shark meat means that there are many distributed outlets for illegal products, and conservation strategies must consider that inspection is unlikely to be viable in such situations. Our results show predominant commercialization of the blue shark (C. glaucus) in Brazil, as previously documented (Staffen et al., 2017; Bernardo et al., 2020). Despite being classified as NT by the IUCN and being listed in Appendix II of CITES, 2025 – Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (Rigby et al., 2019), it is the most common shark caught by longline fishing around the world (Compagno et al., 2005), representing approximately 56% of commercially captured pelagic sharks (Camhi et al., 2009). As pelagic oceanic species, they are not frequently caught by artisanal fishermen and are more commonly landed in Brazil by multinational companies that fish in international waters and that export high-value products, selling the remaining meat (Bornatowski et al., 2015; Barreto et al., 2017; Bernardo et al., 2020). Protected species may end up having their fins exported (Hobbs et al., 2019; Fields et al., 2020) and their meat may eventually be sold in less supervised establishments. Inspection of exported shark fins is a viable and important control point for the conservation of elasmobranchs, especially considering the volume of exports of these products from Brazil (Barbosa-Filho et al., 2017).

Overall, the context dependent analysis of substitution likelihood identified here shows that frozen products from major certified suppliers in Brazil that are generally sold in high-inspection systems and have a low likelihood of substitution but includes some apparently unintentional mislabeling. In contrast, fresh products from local fishmongers in Brazil are low-inspection systems with a higher risk of opportunistic substitution.

Acknowledgments​


We dedicate this work in memoriam to Cristiane A. Torquato. Part of the data analyzed in this article were generated as part of her undergraduate thesis, and we acknowledge her important scientific contribution.

References​


Aljanabi SMM, Martinez I. Universal and rapid salt-extraction of high-quality genomic DNA for PCR-based techniques. Nucleic Acids Res. 1997; 25(22):4692–93. http://doi.org/10.1093/nar/25.22.4692

Almerón-Souza F, Sperb C, Castilho CL, Figueiredo PICC, Gonçalves LT, Machado R et al. Molecular identification of shark meat from local markets in southern Brazil based on DNA barcoding: evidence for mislabeling and trade of endangered species. Front Genet. 2018; 9:138. http://doi.org/:10.3389/fgene.2018.00138

Barbosa-Filho MLV, Costa-Neto EM, Siciliano S. Knowledge and practices of expert fishermen of South Bahia, Brazil, regarding the international shark fin market. Hum Ecol. 2017; 45(1):67–75. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10745-016-9873-2

Barreto RP, Bornatowski H, Motta FS, Santander-Neto J, Vianna GMS, Lessa R. Rethinking use and trade of pelagic sharks from Brazil. Mar Policy. 2017; 85:114–22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2017.08.016

Bernardo C, Adachi AMCL, Cruz VP, Foresti F, Loose RH, Bornatowski H. The label “Cação” is a shark or a ray and can be a threatened species! Elasmobranch trade in southern Brazil unveiled by DNA barcoding. Mar Policy. 2020; 116:103920. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2020.103920

Brasil. Instrução Normativa nº 5, de 21 de Maio de 2004. Reconhecer como espécies ameaçadas de extinção e espécies sobreexplotadas ou ameaçadas de sobreexplotação, os invertebrados aquáticos e peixes, constantes dos Anexos a esta Instrução Normativa. Diário Oficial da União; 2004.

Brasil. Boletim estatístico da pesca e aquicultura Brasil 2008–2009. Ministério da Pesca e Aquicultura – MPA, Brasília, Distrito Federal; 2010.

Brasil. Boletim estatístico da pesca e aquicultura. Brasil 2010. Ministério da Pesca e Aquicultura – MPA, Brasília, Distrito Federal; 2012.

Brasil. Instrução Normativa nº 29, de 23 de Setembro de 2015. Estabelecer, para as principais espécies de peixes de interesse comercial, a correlação entre os seus nomes comuns e respectivos nomes científicos a ser adotada em produtos inspecionados pelo Ministério da Agricultura, Pecuária e Abastecimento e destinados ao comércio nacional. Diário Oficial da União; 2015.

Brasil. Instrução Normativa nº 53, de 01 de Setembro de 2020. Define o nome comum e respectivos nomes científicos para as principais espécies de peixes de interesse comercial destinados ao comércio nacional. Diário Oficial da União; 2020.

Bréchon AL, Hanner R, Mariani S. A systematic analysis across North Atlantic countries unveils subtleties in cod product labelling. Mar Policy. 2016; 69:124–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2016.04.014

Brito MA, Schneider H, Sampaio I, Santos S. DNA barcoding reveals high substitution rate and mislabeling in croaker fillets (Sciaenidae) marketed in Brazil: the case of “pescada branca” (Cynoscion leiarchus and Plagioscion squamosissimus). Food Res Int. 2015; 70:40–46. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodres.2015.01.031

Bornatowski H, Braga RR, Vitule JRS. Shark mislabeling threatens biodiversity. Science. 2013; 340(6135):923. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.340.6135.923-a

Bornatowski H, Navia AF, Braga RR, Abilhoa V, Corrêa MFM. Ecological importance of sharks and rays in a structural food web analysis in southern Brazil. ICES J Mar Sci. 2014; 71:1586–592. http://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsu025

Bornatowski H, Braga RR, Kalinowski C, Vitule RS. “Buying a pig in a poke”: the problem of elasmobranch meat consumption in southern Brazil. Ethnobiol Lett. 2015; 6(1):196–202. http://doi.org/10.14237/ebl.6.1.2015.451

Calegari BB, Reis RE, Alho CS. DNA barcode identification of shark fillet reveals fraudulent commerce in Brazil. Can Soc Forensic Sci J. 2019; 52(2):95–100. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00085030.2019.1581692

Camhi MD, Valenti SV, Fordham SV, Fowler SL, Gibson C. The conservation status of pelagic sharks and rays: report of the IUCN shark specialist group pelagic shark red list workshop. Newbury, UK: IUCN Species Survival Commission Shark Specialist Group; 2009.

Can MF, Günlü A, Can HY. Fish consumption preferences and factors influencing it. Food Sci Technol (Campinas). 2015; 35(2):339–46. https://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1678-457X.6624

Carlson J, Charvet P, Avalos C, Blanco-Parra MP, Briones Bell-lloch A, Cardenosa D et al. Carcharhinus acronotus. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2021:e.T161378A887542. Available from: https://dx.doi.org/10.2305/IUCN.UK.2021-1.RLTS.T161378A887542.en

Carvalho DC, Neto DAP, Brasil BSAF, Oliveira DAA. DNA barcoding unveils a high rate of mislabeling in a commercial freshwater catfish from Brazil. Mitochondrial DNA. 2011; 22(1):97–105. https://dx.doi.org/10.3109/19401736.2011.588219

Carvalho DC, Palhares RM, Drummond MG, Frigo TB. DNA Barcoding identification of commercialized seafood in South Brazil: a governmental regulatory forensic program. Food Control. 2015; 50:784–88. https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2014.10.025

Carvalho DC, Guedes D, Trindade MG, Coelho RMS, Araujo PHL. Nationwide Brazilian governmental forensic programme reveals seafood mislabelling trends and rates using DNA barcoding. Fish Res. 2017a; 191:30–35. https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2017.02.021

Carvalho DC, Palhares RM, Drummond MG, Gadanho M. Food metagenomics: Next generation sequencing identifies species mixtures and mislabeling within highly processed cod products. Food Control. 2017b; 80:183–86. https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2017.04.049

Carvalho GGA, Degaspari IAM, Branco V, Amorim AFCJ, Kennedy VH, Ferreira JR. Assessment of total and organic mercury levels in blue sharks (Prionace glauca) from the South and Southeastern Brazilian Coast. Biol Trace Elem Res. 2014; 159:128–34. https://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12011-014-9995-6

Cawthorn DM, Steinman HA, Witthuhn RC. DNA barcoding reveals a high incidence of fish species misrepresentation and substitution on the South African market. Food Res Int. 2012; 46(1):30–40. https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.foodres.2011.11.011

Cawthorn DM, Baillie C, Mariani S. Generic names and mislabeling conceal high species diversity in global fisheries markets. Conserv Lett. 2018; 11(5):e12573. https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12573

Compagno L, Dando M, Fowler S. A Field Guide to the sharks of the world. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 2005.

Davidson LN, Dulvy NK. Global marine protected areas to prevent extinctions. Nat Ecol Evol. 2017; 1:0040. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-016-0040

Dent F, Clarke S. State of the global market for shark products. Rome, Italy: FAO Fish Aquacult Tech Pap. 2015; 590.

Delpiani G, Delpiani SM, Antoni MD, Ale MC, Fischer L, Lucifora LO et al. Are we sure we eat what we buy? Fish mislabelling in Buenos Aires province, the largest seafood market in Argentina. Fish Res. 2020; 221:105373. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2019.105373

Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal (DIPOA). Anuário dos programas de controle de alimentos de origem animal do DIPOA. Volume 1. Brasília, DF: Secretaria de Defesa Agropecuária, Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal, Coordenação Geral de Programas Especiais; 2015.

Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal (DIPOA). Anuário dos programas de controle de alimentos de origem animal do DIPOA. Volume 2. Brasília, DF: Secretaria de Defesa Agropecuária, Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal, Coordenação Geral de Programas Especiais; 2016.

Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal (DIPOA). Anuário dos programas de controle de alimentos de origem animal do DIPOA. Volume 4. Brasília, DF: Secretaria de Defesa Agropecuária, Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal, Coordenação Geral de Programas Especiais; 2018.

Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal (DIPOA). Anuário dos programas de controle de alimentos de origem animal do DIPOA. Volume 5. Brasília, DF: Secretaria de Defesa Agropecuária, Departamento de Inspeção de Produtos de Origem Animal, Coordenação Geral de Programas Especiais; 2019.

Di Pinto A, Marchetti P, Mottola A, Bozzo G, Bonerba E, Ceci E et al. Species identification in fish fillet products using DNA barcoding. Fish Res. 2015; 170:9–13. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2015.05.006

Donlan CJ, Luque GM. Exploring the causes of seafood fraud: a meta-analysis on mislabeling and price. Mar Policy. 2019; 100:258–64. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2018.11.022

Dulvy NK, Simpfendorfer CA, Davidson LNK, Fordham SV, Bräutigam A, Sant G et al. Challenges and priorities in shark and ray conservation. Curr Biol. 2017; 27(11):565–72. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2017.04.038

Ehmke MD, Bonanno A, Boys K, Smith TG. Food fraud: economic insights into the dark side of incentives. Aust J Agric Resour Econ. 2019; 63(4):685–700. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8489.12346

Espino D, García-Cortés B, Mejuto J. Relationships between size, body weights and fin weight of the blue shark (Prionace glauca) caught as by-catch in the Spanish surface longline fishery in the Indian Ocean. Collect Vol Sci Pap ICCAT. 2010; 65(6):2183–94.

Estrella F, Raposo G, Pascolli J, Gonzalez JG, Motta FS, Moura RL. Comercialização de pescado nas cidades de São Paulo e Rio de Janeiro; 2016.

European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Overview of food price data sources. EFSA Support Publ. 2012; EN-278:1–27.

Feitosa LM, Martins APB, Giarrizzo T, Macedo W, Monteiro IL, Gemaque R et al.DNA-based identification reveals illegal trade of threatened shark species in a global elasmobranch conservation hotspot. Sci Rep. 2018; 8(1):1–11. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-21683-5

Ferrette BLS, Domingues RR, Rotundo MM, Miranda MP, Bunholi IV, De Biasi AL et al. DNA barcode reveals the bycatch of endangered batoids species in the southwest Atlantic: implications for sustainable fisheries management and conservation efforts. Genes. 2019; 10(4):304. https://doi.org/10.3390/genes10040304

Ferrito V, Raffa A, Rossitto L, Federico C, Saccone S, Pappalardo AM. Swordfish or Shark Slice? A rapid response by COIBar–RFLP. Foods. 2019; 8(11):537. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods8110537

Fields AT, Fischer GA, Shea SKH, Zhang H, Feldheim KA, Chapman DD. DNA Zip-coding: identifying the source populations supplying the international trade of a critically endangered coastal shark. Anim Conserv. 2020; 23:670–78. https://doi.org/10.1111/acv.12585

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture 2014. Contributing to Food Security and Nutrition for All. Rome: FAO; 2014.

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture 2016. Contributing to Food Security and Nutrition for All. Rome: FAO; 2016.

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture 2018. Sustainability in action. Rome; 2018. Available from: http://www.fao.org/3/i9540en/i9540en.pdf

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture 2020. Sustainability in action. Rome; 2020. https://doi.org/10.4060/ca9229en

Fox M, Mitchell M, Dean M, Elliott C, Campbell K. The seafood supply chain from a fraudulent perspective. Food Secur. 2018; 10(4):939–63. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12571-018-0826-z

Froese R, Pauly D, editors. FishBase [Internet]. World Wide Web electronic publication; 2020. Available from: www.fishbase.org

Garcia SM, Rosenberg AA. Food security and marine capture fisheries: characteristics, trends, drivers, and future perspectives. Philos Trans R Soc B Biol Sci. 2010; 365:2869–80. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2010.0171

Gemaque R, Monteiro ILP, Gomes F, Sodré D, Sampaio I, Sales JDL et al. Why implement measures to conserve the diversity of Elasmobranchs? The case of the northern coast of Brazil. Rev Biol. 2017; 17(2):1–07. https://doi.org/10.7594/revbio.17.02.01

Gebremedhin S, Bruneel S, Getahun A, Anteneh W, Goethals P. Scientific methods to understand fish population dynamics and support sustainable fisheries management. Water. 2021; 13(4):574. https://doi.org/10.3390/w13040574

Guardone L, Tinacci L, Costanzo F, Azzarelli D, D’Amico P, Tasselli G et al. DNA barcoding as a tool for detecting mislabeling of fishery products imported from third countries: an official survey conducted at the Border Inspection Post of Livorno-Pisa (Italy). Food Control. 2017; 80:204–16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2017.03.056

Hebert PD, Cywinska A, Ball SL, DeWaard JR. Biological identifications through DNA barcodes. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2003; 270(1512):313–21. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2002.2218

Hjorth J. Flat fish filleting machine. US Patent 5,482,502. Washington, DC: U.S. Patent and Trademark Office; 1996.

Hobbs CAD, Potts RWA, Walsh MB, Usher J, Griffiths AM. using dna barcoding to investigate patterns of species utilization in UK shark products reveals threatened species on sale. Sci Rep. 2019; 9:1028. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-38270-3

Jacquet JL, Pauly D. Trade secrets: renaming and mislabeling of seafood. Mar Policy. 2008; 32:309–18. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2007.06.007

Kumar S, Stecher G, Li M, Knyaz C, Tamura K. MEGA X: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis across Computing Platforms. Mol Biol Evol. 2018; 35:1547–49. https://doi.org/10.1093/molbev/msy096

Lo YT, Shaw PC. DNA-based techniques for authentication of processed food and food. Food Chem. 2018; 240:767–74. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2017.08.022

Logan CA, Alter SE, Haupt AJ, Tomalty K, Palumbi SR. An impediment to consumer choice: overfished species are sold as Pacific red snapper. Biol Conserv. 2008; 141:1591–99. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2008.04.007

Lopes CAM, Araujo NLF, Rocha L, Monteiro F, Rocha RCC, Saint’Pierre TD et al. Toxic and essential metals in Narcine brasiliensis (Elasmobranchii: Narcinidae): a baseline ecotoxicological study in the Southeast Atlantic and preliminary maternal transfer implications. Mar Pollut Bull. 2019; 149:110606. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2019.110606

Maciel ES, Sonati JG, Lima LKF, Savay-da-Silva LK, Galvão JA, Oetterer M. Similarities and distinctions of fish consumption in Brazil and Portugal measured through electronic survey. Int Food Res J. 2016; 23(1):395–402.

Marchetti P, Mottola A, Piredda R, Ciccarese G, Di Pinto A. Determining the authenticity of shark meat products by DNA sequencing. Foods. 2020; 9(9):1194. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9091194

Mariani S, Griffiths AM, Velasco A, Kappel K, Jérôme M, Perez-Martin RI et al. Low mislabeling rates indicate marked improvements in European seafood market operations. Front Ecol Environ. 2015; 13:536–40. https://doi.org/10.1890/150119

Massa AE, Palacios DL, Paredi ME, Crupkin M. Postmortem changes in quality indices of ice-stored flounder (Paralichthys patagonicus). J Food Biochem. 2005; 29:570–90. https://doi.org/10.1890/150119

Mejuto J, García-Cortés B. Preliminary relationships between the wet fin weight and the body weight of some large pelagic sharks caught by the spanish surface longline fleet. Collect Vol Sci Pap ICCAT. 2004; 56:243–53.

Palmeira CAM, Rodrigues-Filho LFS, Sales JBL, Vallinoto M, Schneider H, Sampaio I. Commercialization of a critically endangered species (largetooth sawfish, Pristis perotteti) in fish markets of northern Brazil: authenticity by DNA analysis. Food Control. 2013; 34:249–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2013.04.017

Pancaldi F, Galván-Magaña F, González-Armas R, Soto-Jimenez MF, Whitehead DA, O’Hara T et al. Mercury and selenium in the filter–feeding whale shark (Rhincodon typus) from two areas of the Gulf of California, Mexico. Mar Pollut Bull. 2019; 146:955–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2019.07.017

Pazartzi T, Siaperopoulou S, Gubili C, Maradidou S, Loukovitis D, Chatzispyrou A et al. High levels of mislabeling in shark meat – Investigating patterns of species utilization with DNA barcoding in Greek retailers. Food Control. 2019; 98:179–86. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2018.11.019

Potts T, Haward M. International trade, eco-labelling, and sustainable fisheries-recent issues, concepts, and practices. Environ Dev Sustain. 2007; 9:91–106. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-005-9006-3

Purcell SW, Crona BI, Lalavanua W, Eriksson H. Distribution of economic returns in small-scale fisheries for international markets: a value-chain analysis. Mar Policy. 2017; 86:9–16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2017.09.001

Rigby CL, Barreto R, Carlson J, Fernando D, Fordham S, Francis MP et al. Prionace glauca. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species [Internet]. Gland; 2019:e.T39381A2915850. Available from: https://dx.doi.org/10.2305/IUCN.UK.2019-3.RLTS.T39381A2915850.en

Rigby CL, Espinoza M, Derrick D, Pacoureau N, Dicken M. Carcharhinus leucas. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species [Internet]. Gland; 2021:e.T39372A2910670. Available from: https://dx.doi.org/10.2305/IUCN.UK.2021-2.RLTS.T39372A2910670.en

Rodrigues-Filho LFS, Feitosa LM, Nunes JLS, Palmeira ARO, Martins APB, Giarrizzo T et al. Molecular identification of ray species traded along the Brazilian Amazon coast. Fish Res. 2020; 223:105407. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2019.105407

Rodrigues-Filho LFS, Nogueira PC, Sodré D, Leal JRS, Nunes JLS, Rincon G et al. Evolutionary history and taxonomic reclassification of the critically endangered daggernose shark, a species endemic to the Western Atlantic. J Zool Syst Evol Res. 2023; 2023(1):4798805. https://doi.org/10.1155/2023/4798805

Rodrigues-Filho LFS, Rocha TCDR, Rêgo PSD, Schneider H, Sampaio I, Vallinoto M. Identification and phylogenetic inferences on stocks of sharks affected by the fishing industry off the Northern coast of Brazil. Genet Mol Biol. 2009; 32:405–13. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1415-47572009005000039

Rose C, Gribble N, Stapley J. Northern Australian sharks and rays: the sustainability of target and bycatch fisheries, Phase I. FRDC Project 2001/077 Final Report. The State of Queensland, Department of Primary Industries QI 03007; 2003.

Schröder U. Challenges in the Traceability of Seafood. J Verbrauch Lebensm. 2007; 3:45–48. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00003-007-0302-8

Souza DS, Clemente WR, Henning F, Solé-Cava AM. From fish-markets to restaurants: Substitution prevalence along the flatfish commercialization chain in Brazil. Fish Res. 2021; 243:106095. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2021.106095

Staffen CF, Staffen MD, Becker ML, Löfgren SE, Muniz YCN, Freitas RHA. DNA barcoding reveals the mislabeling of fish in a popular tourist destination in Brazil. PeerJ. 2017; 5:e4006. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.4006

Stephenson RL, Wiber M, Paul S, Angel E, Benson A, Charles A et al. Integrating diverse objectives for sustainable fisheries in Canada. Can J Fish Aquat Sci. 2019; 76(3):480–96. https://doi.org/10.1139/cjfas-2017-0345

Stevens JD, Bonfil R, Dulvy NK, Walker PA. The effects of fishing on sharks, rays, and chimaeras (Chondrichthyans), and the implications for marine ecosystems. ICES J Mar Sci. 2000; 57:476–94. https://doi.org/10.1006/jmsc.2000.0724

Vandamme SG, Griffiths AM, Taylor S-A, Di Muri C, Hankard EA, Towne JA et al. Sushi barcoding in the UK: another kettle of fish. PeerJ. 2016; 4:e1891. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.1891

Vaz-dos-Santos AM, Schwingel PR. Biology and fisheries of hake (Merluccius hubbsi) in Brazilian waters, Southwest Atlantic Ocean. In: Arancibia H, editor. Hakes: biology and exploitation. First Edition. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd; 2015.

Vitale S, Biondo F, Giosuè C, Bono G, Okpala COR, Piazza I et al. Consumers’ perception and willingness to pay for eco-labeled seafood in Italian hypermarkets. Sustainability. 2020; 12(4):1434. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12041434

Ward RD, Zemlak TS, Innes BH, Last PR, Hebert PDN. DNA barcoding Australia’s fish species. Phil Trans R Soc B. 2005; 360:1847–57 https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2005.1716

Authors


Jonathan Ready1, Luara Falcão1, Cristiane Araujo2, Bruno Pardinho2, Núbia Guimarães2, Lorena Freitas2, João Bráullio L. Sales1, Izabela S. Mendes2,3 and Daniel Cardoso Carvalho2.4

[1]    Programa de Pós-Graduação em Ecologia Aquática e Pesca, Grupo de Investigação Biológica Integrada, CEABIO/ICB, Universidade Federal do Pará, 66075-750, Belém, PA, Brazil. (JR) jonathan.ready@gmail.com, (LF) luarafalcao@gmail.com, (JBLS) braziliancephalopod@gmail.com.

[2]    Programa de Pós-Graduação em Biodiversidade e Meio Ambiente, Laboratório de Genética da Conservação, Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Minas Gerais, Rua Dom José Gaspar, 500, 30535-901, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil. (CA) c.araujot@ hotmail.com, (BP) pardinho.bruno@gmail.com, (NG) nubiafguimaraes@outlook.com, (LF) lorenabiotec@yahoo.com.br, (ISM) izabelasatosmendes@gmail.com, (DCC) carvalho.lgc@gmail.com (corresponding author).

[3]    MetaGen Soluções Moleculares, Rua Doutor Lucídio Avelar, 27, Buritis, 30493-165, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil.

[4]    Programa de Pós-Graduação em Genética, Instituto de Ciências Biológicas, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil.

Authors’ Contribution


Jonathan Ready: Conceptualization, Supervision, Validation, Writing-original draft, Writing-review and editing.

Luara Falcão: Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Writing-original draft, Writing-review and editing.

Cristiane Araujo: Data curation, Methodology, Resources.

Bruno Pardinho: Data curation, Methodology, Resources.

Núbia Guimarães: Data curation, Methodology, Resources.

Lorena Freitas: Data curation, Methodology.

João Bráullio L. Sales: Formal analysis, Writing-review and editing.

Izabela S. Mendes: Data curation, Methodology, Writing-original draft.

Daniel Cardoso Carvalho: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Resources, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing-original draft, Writing-review and editing.

Ethical Statement​


Not applicable.

Competing Interests


The author declares no competing interests.

Data availability statement


The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

AI statement


The authors did not use any AI-assisted technologies in the creation of this manuscript or its figures.

Funding


This work was supported by projects awarded to DCC by FIP-PUC Minas, Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de Minas Gerais (FAPEMIG), Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES), Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq) and in part by CNPq through Call MCTI/MPA/CNPq Nº 22/2015 – Ordenamento da Pesca Marinha Brasileira (445809/2015–9), by the CAPES both through Call Nº 23/2017 (CAPES-SIU/CAPES-UTFORSK 88887.153852/2017–00) and by the – Finance Code 001, through a scholarship to LHOF through orientation by JSR as part of the Post-Graduate Program in Aquatic Ecology and Fisheries (PPGEAP) and through scholarships to CA, BP, NG and LF through orientation by DCC as part of the Post-Graduate Program in Biodiversity and Environment (PPGBV). JBLS, JSR and DCC are supported by CNPq productivity scholarships (grant numbers 306336/2024–3, 309739/2026-8, 304328/2026-0, respectively).

Supplementary Material


Supplementary material SUP

Peer Review


Peer Review File

How to cite this article


Ready J, Falcão L, Araujo C, Pardinho B, Guimarães N, Freitas L, Sales JBL, Mendes IS, Carvalho DC. Different trade patterns and inspection rates along with the use of umbrella terms results in variable patterns of substitution in shark, hake, and flatfish sold in Minas Gerais, Brazil. Neotrop Ichthyol. 2026; 24(3):e250030. https://doi.org/10.1590/1982-0224-2025-0030


This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Distributed under

Creative Commons CC-BY 4.0

© 2025 The Authors.

Neotropical Ichthyology published by SBI

Accepted August 3, 2026

Submitted February 14, 2025

Epub November 9, 2026